“Momma’s Boys” - the new reality series from Ryan Seacrest
December 17th, 2008Well! We were primed to keep an eye on the new reality show “Momma’s Boys” because, after all, we wrote the definitive book on adult mama’s boys and their romantic relationships with adult daddy’s girls! The show is basically “The Bachelor” meets the mommas from hell! It is so over the top! Ten minutes in, we didn’t think we’d last the length of the first show, much less the whole season.
However, the first episode gave us food for thought where mama’s boys are concerned. Rather than rant about the show, we want to talk about a very real issue for all mama’s boys: from the exaggerated, stereotypical minority that is being exploited on the reality series to the average mama’s boys-next-door who are capable of stable relationships and just need some help understanding themselves and their women (likely daddy’s girls) so that their relationships can be full of love and happiness!
Also, we might have to rant on the show periodically. Some parts of it beg for the attention of a reasonable mind!
For today’s blog entry, the issue raised is how mama’s boys are in the position from childhood, even perhaps infancy, to take the place of the man in their mothers’ lives. It is an invitation they accept for two reasons. The first is loyalty. Out of love they will do their best to be loyal to both their mothers and their fathers, trying to fill their fathers’ shoes. The second reason is that the invitation for a son to take his father’s place is seductive. It makes him feel bigger than he is.
However, he cannot take his father’s place with his mother. It is impossible. Further, no matter how old he gets, he will never be able to take his father’s place! It’s a painful position to be in. A mama’s boy has a greater sense of inadequacy than a father’s son. A mama’s boy will have his shame triggered by his woman more frequently and over smaller issues than a father’s son. It makes life for a mama’s boy complex and painful.
Now, for a little bit of a “rant” about this reality series, “Momma’s Boys,” that should drive our point home. The three bachelors were videotaped with their mothers prior to arriving at the mansion where the 32 women vying for the men’s affection awaited the men and their mothers. One of the men in particular appeared especially uncomfortable standing there with his mother beside him as she went on and on about how he’s a mama’s boy and how much she loves him. That was until he stripped off his shirt and she praised his beautiful body. At that point he beamed! It was disconcerting. You could see the tension between hating being her little boy, even though he is a grown adult, and loving her public admiration of his sculpted body!
No matter what either of them tells themselves about the value of maternal love, he cannot be her man. He cannot fill his father’s shoes. It isn’t possible. And it borders on emotional incest when the dysfunction is this intense!
In another scene, this same mom was fussing with her son because he wished she wouldn’t make his bed for him. She defended her action by saying it caused her discomfort to think of him sleeping in a disheveled bed. Truth be told, the state of his bed is absolutely none of her business. Whether or not it makes her uncomfortable is none of his business. She hasn’t the right to make her discomfort over his disheveled bed his business!
The three mothers on this show have men in their lives (their sons) whom they are free to disrespect, patronize, and humiliate without apology. It begs the question, “What kind of women are they with their husbands?” Are they capable of being adult, sexually functioning women with their husbands? For what are they overcompensating with their sons?
The level of dysfunction on display in the reality series is frightening. These men have tried to fill their fathers’ shoes with their mothers for so long that releasing their mothers appears nearly impossible. Until they do, none of the three will be able to create a real, adult, loving, compassionate, stable relationship with a woman.
They each may leave the show with a woman on their arms. But they will not be able to create a stable love relationship until they can bear the betrayal of releasing their mothers’ hold on them.
Their plight isn’t funny. It isn’t a soap opera. It’s real, deeply imbedded, and painful.